Free Updates

Let us tell you when new posts are added!

Email:

Navigation

Categories
October, 2014 (13)
September, 2014 (17)
August, 2014 (18)
July, 2014 (16)
June, 2014 (18)
May, 2014 (17)
April, 2014 (17)
March, 2014 (17)
February, 2014 (16)
January, 2014 (16)
December, 2013 (11)
November, 2013 (15)
October, 2013 (19)
September, 2013 (20)
August, 2013 (23)
July, 2013 (24)
June, 2013 (14)
May, 2013 (25)
April, 2013 (20)
March, 2013 (24)
February, 2013 (25)
January, 2013 (20)
December, 2012 (19)
November, 2012 (25)
October, 2012 (22)
September, 2012 (24)
August, 2012 (24)
July, 2012 (21)
June, 2012 (22)
May, 2012 (28)
April, 2012 (44)
March, 2012 (36)
February, 2012 (36)
January, 2012 (27)
December, 2011 (22)
November, 2011 (29)
October, 2011 (52)
September, 2011 (26)
August, 2011 (26)
July, 2011 (17)
June, 2011 (31)
May, 2011 (32)
April, 2011 (31)
March, 2011 (31)
February, 2011 (28)
January, 2011 (27)
December, 2010 (34)
November, 2010 (26)
October, 2010 (27)
September, 2010 (27)
August, 2010 (31)
July, 2010 (23)
June, 2010 (30)
May, 2010 (23)
April, 2010 (30)
March, 2010 (30)
February, 2010 (30)
January, 2010 (23)
December, 2009 (19)
November, 2009 (27)
October, 2009 (30)
September, 2009 (25)
August, 2009 (26)
July, 2009 (33)
June, 2009 (32)
May, 2009 (30)
April, 2009 (39)
March, 2009 (35)
February, 2009 (21)
January, 2009 (29)
December, 2008 (15)
November, 2008 (15)
October, 2008 (25)
September, 2008 (30)
August, 2008 (26)
July, 2008 (26)
June, 2008 (22)
May, 2008 (27)
April, 2008 (20)
March, 2008 (20)
February, 2008 (19)
January, 2008 (22)
December, 2007 (21)
November, 2007 (26)
October, 2007 (20)
September, 2007 (17)
August, 2007 (23)
July, 2007 (17)
June, 2007 (13)
May, 2007 (7)

Search

Archives

<October 2014>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2829301234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930311
2345678

More Links








# Tuesday, August 16, 2011
Geni Draws Fire For New User Permissions
Posted by Diane

Geni, a world family tree site where users can build family trees by creating profiles for relatives and ancestors, has made big changes to what paid and free members can do on the site.

In this blog post Aug. 11, Geni announced that free, “Non-Pro” members can no longer add new profiles to the “historical” tree (any public part of the Geni tree) or merge profiles. Free members still can add to their private trees.

Geni Pro subscribers, who pay $4.95 per month for a one-year membership, now “have full permission to add on to, edit, and merge profiles in the historical parts of the tree,” according to the blog post.

Pro users also can search through all the 110 million public profiles on Geni to find relatives to add to their trees. Free members can search and find only their close relatives in the historical tree, as well as profiles they added and profiles they follow.

"Close relatives" means 4th cousins and closer, as well as third-great-grandparents and closer. In-laws are included.

“I'd like to make it clear that Basic (free) users did not lose their ability to view or edit any profiles as part of these changes," says Geni CEO Noah Tutak. “In fact, we did not change view or edit permissions at all. What we did is align permissions in the historical, public sections of the tree, beyond close relatives.”

But comments on Geni's blog post are largely negative. A common theme: Many members, some of whom have added hundreds or thousands of profiles to the site, feel Geni is cutting them off (without advance notice, according to the comments) after encouraging them for years to build its historical tree.

“Losing control” of their public data strikes fear in the hearts of genealogists. They don’t like to idea of others merging their ancestors without having to compare notes first. They have visions of mistaken merges and incorrect names and dates replicating themselves across the internet.

Tutak thinks Geni’s changes will reduce such errors. “These changes were designed to restrict merging to a smaller group of more engaged users, with the goal of increasing data quality,” Tutak says. “If a merge is made in error, the same set of tools are available now as in the past to correct mistakes. In the near future, we'll provide even more robust tools to undo merges that will make correcting these mistakes, which are extremely infrequent, even easier”

Several Pro users commented that they’ll no longer be able to entice relatives—who aren’t likely to purchase Pro subscriptions—to collaborate on building their family trees.

“A member with a free account can build out a large enough tree to get a good feel for the quality of Geni's tools and decide whether or not they would like to use Geni for their entire tree,” says Tutak.

“The number of users contributing to the world [public] family tree is a small percentage of our overall user base, and so far we haven't seen a slowdown in the growth of the tree due to these changes.”

Family tree sites have struggled for years with how to build accurate trees that are large enough to attract additional contributions—that’s why we're still waiting for the trees feature on the new FamilySearch.org to be publicly available. Skewing benefits toward paying users—who, theoretically, are more heavily invested and knowledgeable—is one approach. It’s also likely to anger free members. Many comments on Geni's blog predict that the site won't survive this change.

You can read genealogists’ opinions on the changes at Genea-Musings  and Dear Myrtle


Genealogy Web Sites | Social Networking
Tuesday, August 16, 2011 12:57:49 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [4]
Tuesday, August 16, 2011 4:58:33 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Diana,
It was Tamura Jones who alerted the genealogy community to the changes at Geni.com on her excellent genealogy blog: http://www.tamurajones.net/GeniChanges.xhtml
Let me use your blog to thank her. I am impressed that someone so respected stuck her neck out for us, and that so many other bloggers including you followed her example. We appreciate all your support.
Geni User
Wednesday, August 17, 2011 7:16:20 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
What we are seeing in my opinion is just another example of a larger entity usuing its might to get what it wants. like Ancestry.com before this with it's killing off of it's Expert Connect Program, Geni.com used these people to build there base and then without much or any warning cut them off. Money is a powerful thing, makes most greedy and uncaring. Soory to all of the folks who built their family trees on Geni.com.
Monday, September 26, 2011 4:14:54 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Winter boots also take the black Uggs Canada boots with the same color with the Basic Law of myself, this group with the introverted, practical, if with Ugg Boots Sale white, the contrast and better highlight the personality. The image is known to everyone Pamela - Anderson, also a fan of Uggs Canada Sale UGG; beige and very in tune, with a trace of the handsome sexy tight pants, but this dress may be Ugg Classic Tall the feet of ordinary people still can not accept. But not off a short section is a good mix of partners, especially if you Ugg Classic Boots want to wear enough; It's like Pamela - Anderson for their selection of a light-colored it! The image is known to Uggs Classic everyone Pamela - Anderson, also a fan of UGG; beige and very in tune, with a trace of the handsome sexy tight pants, but this dress may be the feet Moncler Jacket of ordinary people still can not accept. But not off a short section is a good mix of partners, especially Moncler UK if you want to wear enough; It's like Pamela - Anderson for their selection of a light-colored it. The image is known to everyone Pamela - Anderson, also a fan of UGG; beige and Cheap Moncler Jackets very in tune, with a trace of the handsome sexy tight pants, but this dress may be the feet of Moncler Jackets Women ordinary people still can not accept. But not off a short section is a good mix of partners, especially if you want to wear enough; It's like Moncler Jackets Women UK Pamela - Anderson for their selection of a light-colored it! White rice is the most suitable color, her ultra-soft plush comfort and Cheap Moncler Jackets For Women fashion brought innate grace and elegance can easily make you a single step brilliance.
Monday, September 26, 2011 11:30:57 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Who first saw snow boots will be Moncler Jackets the ugly bulky appearance can not understand, but is such a popular boots, the Eurasian Moncler Down Jackets land, and is now in the world have whipped up a popular style, this gust of mainstream stars Cheap Moncler in Europe and America brought. In my impression, snow boots selling shoes similar with Rome. First Online Mens Moncler Jackets overwhelming, after a year in the mall to see the real thing. At this point the network price is two or three hundred, the price is Moncler Down Jackets Men two stores genuine thousand. Whether authentic or imitation products, the above are marked "UGG", so I thought a long time, UGG snow boots Cheap Moncler Jackets For Men are a brand. In fact, snow boots originally called Ugly boots, who was referred to UGG. Snow boots, is the rise Ugg Boots Canada in Australia during the First World War, the Australian pilot with the two pieces of sheepskin wrapped into the shoes Cheap Uggs Canada to wear on their feet warm, then gradually became popular in Australia. From its start-up and subsequent Buy Ugg Boots development, the biggest snow boots feature fur. Sheepskin fur prices high, which stems from the variety of its manufacturing Ugg Classic Cardy processes, stringent accuracy requirements, high prices of raw materials, chemical raw materials expensive. The latter part of last Cardy Uggs century, fur leather processing base from Europe to China, fur leather processing and manufacturing has been fully developed, especially for Merino lamb Ugg Cardy Boots processing process is made more fur quality leather style.
Comments are closed.